top of page

PY2023 RADV Notices Are Out. CRUSH Could Raise the Stakes.

15 hours ago
4 min read
A medical worker works with an electronic database and documents.Technology and access information, database, storage, Digital link tech, big data.

Medicare Advantage organizations received two major Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) signals within days. CMS started Payment Year 2023 audits on November 13, then released its CRUSH proposed rule on November 16.

 

Together, they change the question for plans. It is no longer only whether a record supports a diagnosis. It is how far the result of a small audit sample could eventually reach.

 

Key takeaways


  • CMS began PY2023 Medicare Advantage RADV audits on November 13, 2026.

  • PY2023 medical records are due April 23, 2027.

  • The proposed CRUSH rule would extrapolate RADV findings starting with PY2018 audits.

  • CMS estimates the RADV changes would collect about $9 billion per payment year.

  • CRUSH is not final, and comments are expected to be due January 19, 2027.

 

What Did CMS Start for PY2023 RADV?

 

CMS has launched four of its six scheduled RADV audit years in less than eight months. Its audit schedule shows PY2020, PY2021, PY2024 and PY2023 underway, with PY2022 planned for January to February 2027 and PY2025 for April to May 2027.

 

For PY2023, one industry count puts the audit at 582 contracts. CMS’s audit instructions set out the basics:

  • Who is notified: the CEO, CFO, COO and Medicare Compliance Officer.

  • Sample size: 200 enrollees for the 10 largest contracts, then 100, 50 or 35 based on contract size.

  • Records reviewed: visits from January 1 through December 31, 2022.

  • Record limit: up to two medical records for each audited HCC.

  • Key dates: the enrollee list arrives November 30, submission opens December 4, and records are due April 23, 2027.

 

What Does the CRUSH Rule Propose for RADV?

 

The Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH) proposed rule would make RADV a larger financial issue for Medicare Advantage. CMS ties its RADV reforms to an estimated $21 billion per year in overpayments from inflated risk scores.

 

As summarized by RISE, CMS proposes to:

  • Extrapolate audit findings starting with Payment Year 2018 audits, using results from a sample to estimate overpayments across a contract.

  • Codify no fee-for-service adjuster in RADV calculations.

  • Set the sampling methodology itself.

  • Add hardship exceptions to the RADV regulation.

 

CMS estimates the RADV changes would collect about $9 billion per payment year. The rule is a reissue of sorts: a court vacated the 2023 RADV final rule on procedural grounds in September 2025, and the government appealed that November.

 

This is still a proposal. Comments are expected to be due January 19, 2027, and the final rule could change. The broader rule would also make fraud, waste and abuse referrals mandatory for MA organizations and Part D sponsors.

 

Why Does the Timing Matter for Medicare Advantage Plans?

 

Plans are building PY2023 submissions while the financial rules remain unsettled. CMS’s PY2023 instructions say it has not decided whether to collect extrapolated overpayments, and it reserves the right to do so later. For now, the amount to be collected is the sum of payment errors for sampled enrollees.

 

CRUSH, as proposed, would apply extrapolation to audits from PY2018 forward. If that is finalized, a sample of as few as 35 enrollees could shape an estimate for an entire contract.

 

The workload is also stacking up. Published deadlines put PY2021 records at December 18, PY2024 at February 5 and PY2023 at April 23, so many plans will manage three audits at once.

 

How Should Medicare Advantage Plans Prepare Now?

 

The safest approach is to treat every submitted record as if its result could matter beyond the sample.

  1. Confirm ownership. Name the Lead Point of Contact for each audited contract. CMS allows up to seven contacts per contract.

  2. Map the sample quickly. When the enrollee list arrives, match each audited HCC to the strongest available records.

  3. Choose records carefully. With a limit on submissions, prioritize a record that clearly supports the HCC. One record can support more than one HCC.

  4. Check validity before coding. Confirm the signature, provider credentials, face-to-face requirement and 2022 date of service.

  5. Watch the exceptions. Telehealth needs real-time audio and video. CMS-generated attestations apply to physician and hospital outpatient records, not inpatient records.

  6. Run one calendar across audits. Track PY2021, PY2023 and PY2024 together so one deadline does not pull resources from another.

  7. Model the CRUSH scenario. Bring compliance, finance and legal together to assess possible exposure and decide whether to comment.


RADV and CRUSH FAQ


What is a RADV audit?


A Risk Adjustment Data Validation audit checks whether medical records support the diagnoses a Medicare Advantage organization submitted for risk-adjusted payment.


When are PY2023 RADV records due?


CMS’s PY2023 instructions set the medical record submission deadline at 11:59 p.m. EST on April 23, 2027.


What is RADV extrapolation?


Extrapolation uses the payment error found in an audit sample to estimate overpayments across a contract.


Is the CRUSH rule final?


No. CRUSH is a proposed rule, and CMS can change it after reviewing public comments.


Does CRUSH apply to PY2023 audits?


As proposed, extrapolation would apply to audits from PY2018 forward. The final rule will determine what applies.


The Bottom Line

RADV is becoming a continuous operating requirement, not a once-in-a-while audit event. Plans that tighten record selection, validation and deadline management now will be better prepared, whatever CMS finalizes.

Our team helps Medicare Advantage organizations with risk adjustment and RADV, and we are working with plans on both now. Contact us to talk through where your plan stands before the next deadline.


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page